This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

Tim Keefer – Founder & Managing Director, The Original Island Shrimp House

The Original Island Shrimp House

12902 South LaGrange Road

Palos Park, IL 60464

Hours of Operation: Mondays, closed; Tuesdays – Thursdays, 11:30AM – 9PM, Fridays – Saturdays, 11AM – 9PM, Sundays, 11:30AM – 8PM




Lobster Quesadilla with Fresh Corn Salad

 1 scoop Lobster Salad (recipe below)

12” Flour Tortilla (jalapeno cheddar flavored tortilla or other flavors of cheese)

Finely Shredded Cheese (we use Monterey jack/cheddar blend)

Spice blend (a little heat & a little savory flavor)

 Lobster Salad

1-pound fresh lobster meat

Spice blend (1/4 teaspoon Old Bay)

1 cup finely diced fresh celery

1-2 freshly squeezed lemons (to taste)

4 Tablespoons high-grade mayonnaise

Directions: Add all ingredients to a bowl.  Mix well.  Adjust spice and lemon to taste. Chill.

Note:  There is a synergy with the combination of spice, the lemon and mayo which when achieved, raises the sweetness of the lobster salad.  This is a desirable goal.  Remember, add these ingredients in small amounts as you can always add more, but you cannot take them out!

Sweet Corn Salad

6 ears fresh sweet corn (cooked and cut from the cob)

½ fresh sweet onion, finely diced

½ red pepper, finely diced

1 jalapeno (most of the seeds removed – leave some for heat; if desired)

1 tomato, finely diced

1 generous handful cilantro

Olive oil (enough to coat ingredients)

1-2 fresh limes (to taste)

Salt and pepper, pinch (to taste)


1 – Boil corn (husk on) for 5-7 minutes (optionally strip most of the husk reserving a few layers of husk and optionally place on charcoal grill for an additional 10 minutes, turning frequently)

2 – Let corn cool.  Cut off kernels to make about 5 cups.

3 – Prepare vegetables by finely dicing white or sweet onion, red pepper, jalapeno, tomato and cilantro.  Place in bowl.

4 – Add corn to bowl.  Add olive oil.

5 – Mix well and add fresh squeezed lime, salt and pepper to taste.

6 – Cover and let stand about an hour for flavors to “marry.” Chill and serve.

Best if eaten within 2 days.

 DIRECTIONS (for Quesadilla):

1 – Lightly oil skillet large enough to heat tortilla.  Place tortilla in skillet over medium heat, distribute cheese evenly over whole tortilla.

2 – Simultaneously, place finely diced lobster salad in skillet and constantly rotate to heat (be careful, as this heats quickly)

3 – Add heated lobster to ½ of the tortilla – spread evenly.

4 – Fold tortilla in half so the cheese only half covers the cheese/lobster half.

5 – Leave over heat for 1 minute or so.

6 – Remove from heat and cut into evenly divided pieces and plate.